May you come to the attention of those in authority
May you find what you are looking for
May you live in interesting times
—Legendary Chinese Curses
Coming up on the sixth anniversary of 9/11, I've just finished editing part of a fiction manuscript that uses it as its backdrop. This far away from it, I didn't think it would bother me much to read about it, but it did, particularly one scene where the main character is fleeing from Lower Manhattan across the Brooklyn Bridge with his employees, carrying servers and hard drives and pursued by a roiling wall of ash and pulverized building materials. The image it conjured up was something like this sandstorm in Iraq, filmed not too long ago by a soldier stationed there:
And that image sparked the beginnings of a poem, which I have yet to write. I've been planning to take the initial 15 poems I wrote for Stories From the Ruins (not the prose poem) and write more, to make it a full-blown collection. But now I'm not so sure. Now I don't know if I really do have enough distance from it.
I started thinking about this after reading the Author2Author conversation between TJ Fisher and Joshua Clark, two New Orleans authors, on Beatrice. Clark, right off the bat, says that the disaster of living through Katrina in the French Quarter broke a 7-year-long writer's block for her. In her words, "a torrent of emotions and words flowed out of me like floodwaters." That really struck a chord with me, because I felt the same way immediately after 9/11. I hadn't been suffering from writer's block, but I was suddenly suffering from logorrhea (hence the name of the blog that originated then, of which this one is the spawn). I couldn't stop writing because writing is a way of working through my thoughts, or "processing" as shrinks say. But it's also true that disasters tend to breed interesting stories. This is why Anna Karenina starts with the line, "Happy families are all alike; every unhappy family is unhappy in its own way."
It's not that happiness is bad; god knows we all want it and most of us deserve it. But unhappiness, especially big unhappinesses—natural disasters, war and other intentional violent acts, mass accidents—force us to look at ourselves and each other, our society and our world, in ways that the state of happiness forestalls. They jolt us out of our complacency, scare the shit out of us, and drop us back into a world that's just a little—or sometimes a lot—different from before. It changes our point of view just a little.
And sometimes it scars us. I won't say that I've actually been scarred, but I've definitely been changed by 9/11. Like many New Yorkers, I'm quicker to fear unusual occurrences than I was before the Towers were attacked. I'm quicker to think they're intentionally hurtful rather than the result of bad odds. When the steam pipe exploded in Midtown in July, recreating the chaos of 9/11 in miniature, my first thought was a bomb, like many New Yorkers. When it turned out to be just crumbling infrastructure, I was relieved, but that didn't stop the pictures of vapor rising from Midtown from reminding me of smoke from the Pile with an added frisson of fear.
But maybe that's a good thing, or at least something I can use as a writer. Later in that Author2Author conversation, Joshua Clark adds that,
Forcing myself to write this book, there certainly was a purging of emotions—has anyone ever had to write a memoir about a national tragedy this soon?—and it's forced me to deal with many things that many New Orleanians have avoided and hence continue (and will probably always continue) to suffer from.
Maybe that's part of the job of being a writer: dealing with things other people avoid. Stating the obvious. Telling the Emperor he's naked. Pointing out that it's normal to think a steam pipe explosion was a bomb, that being made to think it might have been makes us more susceptible to manipulation by unscrupulous people in power. If writing is a way of processing, then reading can be too. If Clark and Fisher can bring themselves to write so passionately about their drowned city so soon afterwards, there's no reason for me not to face the ghosts of 9/11 six years later.
I'm gonna go write that poem now.