« Retail Wonderland | Main | New Book: Border & Frontier »

April 26, 2006

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Jennifer Ouellette

Excellent analysis of the situation, and precisely why I thought you'd be such a good person to address it. But I feel I should point that your post's title echoes of that of one of my own posts ("Mediagenics 101"). Humph! Plagiarist. :)

Lee Kottner

Cultural trope or shameless stealing? You be the judge!
Of course, it could have just been an homage to your brilliance, Jen.

Erica

The line between "homage" plagiarism and plain old being derivative is fine enough, then one has to allow for the issues of tedious, i.e."classic," tropes of any genre.

Fiction is not, as most people assume, a coherent single thing. It is a large body of may things, all of which are informed by many other things. It's at least in part the author's job to be aware of what parts of their writing are informed and shaped by what influences - your blog is frequently about just that, isn't it? :-) The rest of the responsibility lies solely on the editor's shoulders. I have friends in the industry whose job it is to catch all these mistakes and point them out. (And they are ignored a great deal of the time, which will surprise no one, I'm sure.)

The author *is* culpable for not being aware that she stole whole chunks of writing. Of course she shouldn't be crucified - she should have been stopped however. Save the vitriol for the editor and publisher, who failed, utterly, at their jobs.

When I steal a bit from a writer - even if it's a bit that I can safely use because it's not word-for-word, but a conceptual thing, I know it. If I'm writing fanfiction, I point it out. "I stole a bit from Dorothy L. Sayer - if you're a fan of her work, you'll know immediately which bit it is." In my "original" fiction, I've inevitably used ideas and concepts from quite literally hundreds of sources - so who is to say that the work is original?

When I was in Illinois discussing my novel with a reading club, I was asked by one of the attendees why I relied on an old chestnut as a plot complication at one point. I was surprised, not because I didn't think it was a "classic" theme, but because you only have so many choices when creating certain situations - ANY choice would have been done to death! LOL

Like I always say, whatever you came up with - Shakespeare already did it and better, so just give up on the idea of originality and you'll be happier. :-)

Lee Kottner

Erica sez: "The author *is* culpable for not being aware that she stole whole chunks of writing. Of course she shouldn't be crucified - she should have been stopped however."

I couldn't agree more. In this case, it's rather like the "insane but guilty" option some states have in criminal cases. Did Viswanathan plagiarize McCafferty? Sure looks that way. Is she responsible for her actions? Yes. But she's not the only one responsible. Where was her editor, and why is she not being hung out to dry as well? I'd also like to know why Stephen Ambrose gets a slap on the wrist for plagiarizing other historians when Viswanathan gets cricified for it.

The comments to this entry are closed.

My Photo

My Artist's Books

  • Border and Frontier

    Add to Your Collection

  • Stories From the Ruins

    Add to Your Collection

  • Highfield's Recipes From a Good Life

    Not For Sale

Poets, Poetry, Poetry Orgs

  • A Gathering of the Tribes
    Since 1991, A Gathering of the Tribes has been run as an alternative arts and literary scene at the home of its executive director, Steve Cannon.
  • Academy of American Poets
    Sponsors National Poetry Month in April and has a huge audio archive of readings, much of it available online. They even have an iPhone app!
  • Cave Canem
    Founded by Toi Derricotte and Cornelius Eady in 1996 to remedy the under-representation and isolation of African American poets in the literary landscape, Cave Canem Foundation is a home for the many voices of African American poetry and is committed to cultivating the artistic and professional growth of African American poets.
  • City Lore
    City Lore is the co-sponsor (with Poets House) of the biennial poetry festival in downtown Manhattan showcasing the nation’s – and the world’s – literary and folk poetry traditions with special attention to poetry’s oral roots.
  • EMOTIVE FRUITION – Where poetry comes to life.
    An interesting group that matches poets with actors for performances of their work.
  • Howl Festival
    The annual Poetry, Theater, Performance Art, Film Comedy and Dance festival in the East Village, usually in September. Named after Allen Ginsberg’s poem.
  • Nuyorican Poets Cafe
    Slams, literary events, readings, music, theater. Founded ca. 1973, originally as a home salon by lit professor Miguel Algarin. Old School slammin'. Don't miss it.
  • Poets House: A Place for Poetry
    Newly renovated and fantastically beautiful: a vast library of poetry books; literary center for readings and performances.
  • St. Mark's Poetry Project
    Started in 1966, the Poetry Project was one of the inspirations for the Nuyorican Poets Cafe. In addition to weekly readings and workshops, they hold a 24-hour poetry reading on New Year’s Day each year.
  • Taiku Poetry
    Tanoa's Haiku an American original
  • The Inspired Word
    Mike Geffner's biweekly showcase of fantastic poets and open mics.
  • The Urban Juke Joint on FaceBook
  • Theodora Goss: Poems
  • WandaLeaBrayton - poet at allpoetry
AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Crosstown Traffic

Blog powered by Typepad
Member since 10/2003

Fellow Travelers

Web Comics