Every now and then I get this notion that I should, you know, be a little more feminine. Usually, I have to be shamed into it, by a certain type of woman. At moments like these, it has never been clearer to me that gender is a construct and I'm missing the foundation.
Mom, who was an incorrigible tomboy herself as a child (her nickname was Jimmy), used to try valiantly to send me to school in dresses. I would have none of it. In the frigid Michigan winters, she'd send me off to elementary school in a turtleneck, a jumper, and a pair of pants to keep my legs warm, which were to be removed at school, revealing tights underneath. Guess what got left in the locker?
My best friend, who is a naturally girly girl and blonde, too, and I could not have been more Mutt-and-Jeff in the girly department if we'd tried. She actually wore dresses voluntarily. (Ew!) She had an early acquaintance with nail polish and managed to have pretty, long nails despite being a pianist from the age of four. Mel finally shamed me into wearing makeup late in junior high, a practice that went mostly out the window when I discovered feminism in college, and then came in through the bathroom window again when the punk and goth looks were popular in grad school and I could wear lots of fun colors of eyeshadow all at once and safety pins in my ears. I'm now down to coverup, blush, powder, and polish on my toenails in the summer. Sometimes I go out without any makeup on at all.
But never to work. Especially now.
No, now I sit next to the ultra-girly C. who is almost a stereotype, if she were not also smart (I caught her reading Dostoyevsky the other day, for fun). C. is in her late 20s/early 30s—the next generation behind me. Her heels are never less than 3 inches. She wears skirts the majority of the time. She refreshes her makeup before going to play softball with the office team, and she was distressed to get her new sneakers dirty when playing. She is slim, dark-haired with clear olive skin, sexy as all get out, and knows how to accentuate it. I admire her show-off style. I love her shoes. I covet her jewelry.
Secretly, I hate C., the way I hated Mel in junior high, even though she was (and is) my best friend. They are always turned out so nicely, so neatly, and look so feminine. Their clothes do not wrinkle and they always look fresh. Above all, their clothes manage to stay clean all day. Imagine that.
Next to them, I am Pig Pen—the Peanuts character who walks around in a cloud of dirt. I put on a clean shirt in the morning, and by the time I get out of the subway and walk down the street to work, I have collected grease spots on the front of it, without having anything in my hands. In sandals, my feet collect enough New York City dirt to pave another street, maybe even an avenue. Somehow, I manage to smudge blue ink from a "received" stamp on a magazine cover onto my new white pants the first time I wear them. I gave up wearing mascara long ago, because it will inevitably wind up somewhere other than my eyelashes. Ditto with lipstick. One day I went to work and found my shirt somehow covered in gear grease. I suspect I collected it leaning against a subway pillar somewhere. Oh, and the gum on the back of my pantleg from the underside of a subway bench? That was not amusing either. This is why I wear so much black: because New York is dirty and the dirt here likes me.
I don't buy really nice clothes because I can't afford to wear them once and then toss them out when they're irreparably stained. This is not to say I don't clean up well. When I do wear good clothes—and I do own some, wise guys—everyone's a little shocked. Hey! She knows how to wear a dress! And lipstick! And heels! Look! She's got legs! Oh, ha ha. Very funny. But I can only pull it off, like Cinderella, for a few hours at a time. After that, my girl warranty runs out and I turn into a bumpkin.
Anyway, I've never quite managed to accustom myself to girly accouterments. I find most purses annoying and awkward. They don't stay on my shoulder and they're not comfortable strung between a pair of D-cups. And belt pouches are just ugly. But where do I put my wallet, PDA, cellphone, Kleenex and pens?
High heels? Not even if hell freezes over. We all know women's shoes are not made for stability, and despite all those ballet lessons, any crack in the sidewalk will trip me up in even small heels. The pair that sent me down the stairs head first had measly 1-inch Cuban heels. Another pair threw me to the ground because they were short but too narrow.
Pantyhose, the bane of every woman's life and product of the devil, are pretty much impossible now. My fingertips are rough enough to snag anything more delicate than tights. I don't even buy them anymore.
Side zip pants? Whose bright freakin' idea were those? That's like a side-fastening bra. Worse even than back-zip pants.
And slips. I can't tell you the last time I wore a slip, since they always ride up around my waist anyway. What's the point? If I have to wear a skirt, it's going to be opaque material, or everybody gets to see what I look like in the bottom half of a bathing suit.
Sometimes, I can't even manage the jewelry. I just bought several beautiful new strings of dyed freshwater pearls for dirt cheap. They snag and pull all the hair on my neck and they don't stay draped evenly, even if they're tripled around my neck, where they manage to choke me. Brooches fall off me within fifteen minutes of putting them on. You wouldn't believe how many I've lost. This is another item I don't buy anymore.
I was thinking the other day I wish I'd never started shaving my legs. Once you do it, you're kind of locked into it because they're too blunt and bristly to grow out. I probably couldn't haven't gotten away with it anyway, with my dark hair and pale skin, but it would have saved me the grief of shaving every day in the summer. I have a five-o'clock shadow if I don't. If stubble were fashionable for women, I would be wearing it. Another reason I wear pants so often.
Basically, I'm not built for girliness. I'm short and round, low to the ground, and though I've got a cute face and those D-cups, I ain't built for short skirts and high heels and anything below the knee makes me look like an old fashioned Italian widow. I have, in my day, played a mean game of tennis, biked 15 miles a day every summer for several years, painted way more walls than I want to think about, fixed plumbing and small engines, and cut my own bait.
So at 45, I guess it's too late to be a girly girl. I actually made this remark to C. the other day, as one of the guys I have a mild crush on wandered by. He's adorably fresh out of school and it would be worse than Demi and Ashton, but never mind. It cracked him up and that amused me. C., to her credit, got after him about it, though his response didn't bother me. I was glorying in my secret knowledge that I don't mind getting my sneakers dirty.